APPENDIX 10.3 CRASH TABLES
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS- POSSIBLE ACTIONS
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: INTERSECTION - REAR-END
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
---|---|---|
Capacity | Head-on with turning vehicle | Are turning volumes heavy? Are through lanes blocked by turning vehicles? Is the intersection capacity adequate?
At traffic signals Is the signal timing adequate (length of each phase, necessity of an exclusive turning phase)? Is there an unusual signal sequence that may confuse drivers? |
Protection Turning manoeuvres | Head-on with turning vehicle | Are vehicles completing non-priority turning manoeuvres separated from through vehicles? |
Surface condition | Wet-surface crashes Single-vehicle crashes | Is skid resistance adequate?
Check for hazardous manoeuvres that may be related to surface deficiencies (potholes, waves, other deformations, water accumulation). |
Drivers’ behaviour | Right-angle collisions, Head-on with turning vehicles | Are available sight distances sufficient to allow safe braking and manoeuvring at intersection?
|
Sight distance | Right angle collisions Single vehicle crashes | Are available sight distances sufficient to allow safe braking and manoeuvring at intersection?
|
Unexpected intersection | Right-angle collisions Single-vehicle crashes | Is the intersection conspicuous? Is the presence of the intersection coherent in the road environment?
|
Road access | Access-related crashes | Are crashes related to manoeuvres at access points near the intersection? Is the presence of the access expected (visibility, road category)? Is access geometry adequate (width, channelization, additional lane)?
|
Road lighting | Nighttime crashes | Are crashes occurring at night? Check for the presence and condition of the road lighting system (at night) |
Presence of pedestrians or cyclists | Collisions with pedestrians or cyclists | Are crossing pedestrians/cyclists clearly visible?
|
Weather conditions | Crashes under adverse conditions (rain, fog, etc.) | Plan the site visit when adverse conditions are likely to be observed. |
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: INTERSECTION - REAR-END
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
---|---|---|
Capacity | Add turning lane and channelization. Prohibit turning manoeuvres. Change signal timing (exclusive turning lane). | |
Protection Turning manoeuvres | Add turning lane, channelization. Pave shoulders. Prohibit turning manoeuvres. |
|
Surface condition | Proceed to superficial surface treatments (grooving, sand blasting, etc). Resurface. Improve drainage conditions. Correct structural deficiencies. Add warning sign (temporary measure). | |
Drivers’ behaviour | Increase visibility of stop signs/signal heads/intersection. Install advance-warning signs. Implement traffic-calming measures. Increase drivers’ education and police enforcement. Install surveillance cameras. | |
Sight distance | Install warning signs/devices. Remove sight obstructions. Separate turning vehicles in exclusive lanes. Prohibit turning manoeuvres. | |
Unexpected intersection | Increase intersection conspicuity through road signs, channelization, road lighting, landscaping; elimination of competing information (street parking, stands, advertising, etc.). Re-design intersection (e.g. roundabout). Close/relocate intersection. | |
Road access | Improve access geometry. Prohibit some access-related manoeuvres (median barrier, traffic island). Close/relocate access. |
|
Road lighting | Install or improve road lighting. | Are crashes occurring at night? Check for the presence and condition of the road lighting system (at night) |
Presence of pedestrians or cyclists | Improve pedestrian/cyclist visibility (crossing, parking prohibition, etc.). Separate pedestrians/cyclists and motorized traffic (traffic signal, exclusive phase, grade-separated crossing). | |
Weather conditions | Improve maintenance. Install warning signs (e.g. wind gusts, fog). |
|
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: HEAD-ON WITH TURNING VEHICLE
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
---|---|---|
Capacity | Rear-end collisions | Are turning volumes heavy? Are through lanes blocked by turning vehicles? Is the intersection capacity adequate?
At traffic signals Is the signal timing adequate (length of each phase, necessity of an exclusive turning phase)? Is there an unusual signal sequence that may confuse drivers? |
Protection Turning manoeuvres | Rear-end collisions | Are vehicles completing non-priority turning manoeuvres separated from through vehicles? Are turning drivers hurrying their manoeuvres to avoid approaching vehicles from behind? |
Drivers’ behaviour | Rear-end collisions Right-angle collisions | Check for short gap acceptance, red light running or excessive speed May turning drivers have difficulties in estimating the speed of opposing vehicles? |
Sight distance | Right angle collisions Single vehicle crashes | Are available sight distances sufficient to allow safe turning manoeuvres?
At traffic signals
|
Road access | Access-related crashes | Are crashes related to manoeuvres at access points near the intersection? Is the presence of the access expected (visibility, road category)? Is access geometry adequate (width, channelization, additional lane)? |
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: HEAD-ON WITH TURNING VEHICLE
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
Capacity | Add turning lane and channelization. Install all-way stops. Install traffic signals, add an exclusive turning phase. Prohibit turning manoeuvres. Change intersection into roundabout. | |
Protection Turning manoeuvres | Add turning lane and channelization. Pave shoulders. Prohibit turning manoeuvres. | |
Drivers’ behaviour | Install traffic signal with exclusive turning phases, increase the duration of change intervals (yellow, all red). Implement traffic-calming measures. Increase drivers’ education. Increase police enforcement. | |
Sight distance | Remove sight obstructions. Prohibit turning manoeuvres. Modify right-of-way rules (all-way stops, exclusive turning phases). | |
Road access | Improve access visibility. Improve access geometry (width, channelization, merging/diverging lane). Prohibit some access-related manoeuvres (median barrier, traffic islands). Close/relocate access. |
|
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: INTERSECTION-RIGHT-ANGLE
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
Capacity | Rear-end collisions | Are turning volumes heavy? Are through lanes blocked by turning vehicles? Is the intersection capacity adequate?
At traffic signals Is the signal timing adequate (length of each phase, necessity of an exclusive turning phase)? Is there an unusual signal sequence that may confuse drivers? |
Sight distance | Rear-end collisions Single-vehicle crashes | Are available sight distances sufficient to allow safe manoeuvres?
At traffic signals
|
Drivers’ behaviour | Rear-end collisions Head-on with turning vehicle | Check for short gap acceptance, red light running or excessive speed. |
Road signs |
| Do road signs conform with standards (sequence, size, location, height)? Is the stop sign clearly visible?
|
Marking |
| Is the stop line clearly visible? Are vehicles stopped position safe? |
Road width |
| Are manoeuvring difficulties increased by excessive lane or roadway width? |
Turning radii |
| Excessive radii Check for the presence of wide turning radii that encourage incomplete stopping manoeuvres and excessive turning speeds. Insufficient radii Check for the presence of insufficient turning radii that force heavy vehicles to encroach in adjacent lanes. |
Unexpected intersection | Rear-end collisions Single-vehicle crashes | Is the presence of the intersection likely to surprise drivers unfamiliar with the area?
|
Weather conditions | Crashes under adverse conditions (rain, fog, etc.) | Plan the site visit when adverse conditions are likely to be observed. |
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: INTERSECTION-RIGHT-ANGLE
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
Capacity | Install all-way stops. Install traffic signals, change timing. Add channelization (median refuge). Prohibit some manoeuvres. Change intersection into roundabout. | |
Sight distance | Install warning signs/devices. Remove sight obstructions (trees, parking spaces near the intersection, etc.). Prohibit turning manoeuvres. Modify right-of-way rules (all-way-stops, signal phasing). Improve signal lenses visibility (location, angle, visors, etc.). | |
Drivers’ behaviour | Install advance-warning signs. Install traffic signals. Increase visibility of stop signs/signal lenses. Implement traffic-calming measures. Increase drivers’ education. Increase police enforcement. Install surveillance cameras. | |
Road signs | Improve road signs. |
|
Marking | Improve marking (e.g. stop lines). |
|
Excessive road width | Reduce lane/road width (median refuge, other islands, marking). Install traffic signals, change timing. |
|
Turning radii | Modify turning radii (channelize, improve marking). Modify lane widths. |
|
Unexpected intersection | Increase intersection conspicuity:
Re-design intersection (e.g. roundabout). Close/relocate intersection. |
|
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: INTERSECTION- PEDESTRIAN/CYCLIST
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
Insufficient protection |
| Do existing facilities provide adequate protection for pedestrians?
Traffic signals
Have safety needs of all pedestrian categories been properly considered?
|
Sight distance |
| Are pedestrians and cyclists clearly visible when crossing?
Traffic signals Are pedestrian signal heads clearly visible to pedestrians (e.g. hidden by a stopped bus)? |
Behaviour |
| Speed
Drivers of motorized vehicles
Pedestrians/cyclists
|
Road lighting | Nighttime crashes |
|
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: INTERSECTION- PEDESTRIAN/CYCLIST
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
Insufficient protection | Add or improve crossing facilities, their location or their signing. Install traffic signals with an exclusive pedestrian phase. Provide grade-separated crossing. Provide adequate protection for particular pedestrian needs. (e.g. audible traffic signal for blind people). |
|
Sight distance | Install warning signs/devices. Remove sight obstructions (e.g. relocate street parking). Relocate crossing. Change right-of-way rules. Improve signal lens visibility. | |
Speed and other behaviour | Improve road signs. Increase separation between pedestrians/cyclists and motorized road users (exclusive phase, median refuge, grade-separated crossings barriers to guide pedestrians to designated crossings). Implement traffic-calming measures. Increase drivers’ education. Increase police enforcement. Install speed cameras. | |
Road lighting | Install or improve road lighting. |
|
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: SECTION- SINGLE VEHICLE
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
---|---|---|
Horizontal alignment | Head-on collisions Wet-surface crashes | Is the horizontal curve clearly visible? Are significant speed reductions required when approaching the curve? [speed differentials] Are warning signs and devices adapted to road conditions (e.g. first sharp curve)? Check for late braking, brake marks, encroachments. |
Vertical alignment | Crashes involving trucks Rear-end collision | Are grade characteristics obvious (e.g., compound grade)? Check for potential sources of traffic conflicts, particularly at hill bottom. Are warning signs and devices adapted to grade conditions? Is brake overheating possibility low? Is safety equipment adapted to hill features and traffic conditions (check brake area, arrester bed)? Do features of truck lanes allow safe traffic operation? (alignment, lane length, taper features) Are truck downhill speeds safe |
Cross- section | Head-on collisions Sideswipe collisions | Is the general aspect of the road cross-section adequate for the road category and traffic conditions (e.g. too narrow lanes for heavy vehicles)? Are channelization features safe (curb height, alignment, end treatment). Is transition adequate at cross section change (divided/undivided, lane drop)? Are rumble strips provided if required? Check for encroachments, lane/shoulder drop-off. |
Surface condition | Wet-surface crashes Rear-end collisions | Is skid resistance adequate?
Check for hazardous manoeuvres that may be related to avoidance manoeuvres of surface deficiencies (potholes, waves, other deformations, water accumulation). |
Roadside conditions |
| Are roadsides free of features that may increase the severity of losses of control (e.g. steep side slopes, rigid obstacles, inadequate end treatment of structures). |
Sight distance |
| Are available sight distances sufficient to allow safe stopping manoeuvres?
Check for sources of traffic conflicts or road hazards where sight is restricted (intersection, crossing, access, narrow structure, etc.). |
Road access | Access-related collisions | Are crashes related to manoeuvres at accesses? Is the presence of access expected (visibility, road category)? Is access geometry adequate (width, channelization, merging/diverging lane)? |
Speed | Head-on collisions | Are operating speeds compatible with safe traffic operation (based on road characteristics). |
Road lighting | Nighttime crashes | Check the frequency of night crashes. Check the presence and condition of the road lighting system (at night). |
Animals | Crashes with animals | Check the frequency of crashes with an animal. |
Weather conditions | Crashes under adverse weather conditions (rain, fog, etc.) | Plan the site visit when adverse conditions are likely to be observed. |
Combination of features |
| Is there a combination of features that may increase the crash risk or its severity (horizontal curve, hill, intersection, access, narrow bridge, etc.). |
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: SECTION- SINGLE VEHICLE
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
Horizontal alignment | Improve warning signs/devices (marking, delineation). Improve geometry (superelevation, shoulders, skid resistance, roadside conditions, curve radius). | |
Vertical alignment | Improve warning signs/devices. Provide safety equipment (check brake area, arrester bed). Improve geometry (cross-section, roadside conditions, grade). | |
Cross- section | Widen lane or shoulder width. Improve shoulder condition. Install channelization. Provide rumble strips |
|
Surface condition | Proceed to superficial surface treatment (grooving, sand blasting, etc). Resurface. Improve drainage conditions. Correct structural deficiencies. Add warning sign (temporary measure). | |
Roadside conditions | Improve roadside conditions (removal, displacement, protection or fragilization of fixed objects; side-slopes smoothing). |
|
Sight distance | Install warning signs/devices. Improve sight distance. Eliminate traffic conflict possibilities where sight is restricted. | |
Road access | Improve access geometry. Prohibit some access-related manoeuvres (median barrier, traffic island). Close/relocate access. |
|
Speed | Improve visibility of speed limit signs. Implement traffic-calming measures. Increase drivers’ education. Increase police enforcement. Install surveillance cameras. | |
Road lighting | Install or improve the road lighting system. |
|
Animals | Install warning signs. Install fences, grade-separated crossings. |
|
Weather conditions | Improve maintenance. Install warning signs (e.g. fog). |
|
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: SECTION- REAR END
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
Capacity |
| Is the capacity adequate? calculate capacity, levels of service. travel times, platoons. Are crashes occurring at peak hours? Turning movements Are through lanes blocked by turning vehicles? |
Unexpected congestion | Multi-vehicle crashes | Plan the site visit when congestion is likely to be observed. |
Road access | Access-related crashes | Are crashes related to manoeuvres at accesses? Is the presence of access expected (visibility, road category)? Is access geometry adequate (width, channelization, merging/diverging lane)? |
Sight distance |
| Are available sight distances sufficient to allow safe stopping manoeuvres?
Check for sources of traffic conflicts or road hazards where sight is restricted (intersection, crossing, access, narrow structure, etc.). |
Drivers’ behaviour | Single-vehicle crashes | Check for excessive speeds, tailgating, hazardous passing manoeuvres. |
Surface condition | Wet-surface crash Rear-end collisions | Is skid resistance adequate? surface polishing, bleeding, contamination. |
Weather conditions | Crashes under adverse weather conditions (rain, fog, etc.) | Plan the site visit when adverse conditions are likely to be observed. |
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: SECTION- REAR END
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
Capacity | Add lane, channelization. Prohibit turning manoeuvres (median barrier). Promote alternative route or transportation solution (e.g. transit). | |
Unexpected congestion | Install active warning signs/devices. Reduce congestion (through geometric improvements or traffic management). Increase police surveillance. |
|
Road access | Improve access geometry (merging/diverging lane). Prohibit some access-related manoeuvres (median barrier, traffic islands). Close/relocate accesses
|
|
Sight distance | Install warning signs/devices. Improve sight distance. Prohibit turning manoeuvres where sight is restricted. | |
Drivers’ behaviour | Increase visibility of speed-limit signs. Implement traffic-calming measures. Increase drivers’ education. Increase police enforcement. Install surveillance cameras. | |
Surface condition | Proceed to superficial surface treatment (grooving, sand blasting, etc). Resurface. Improve drainage conditions. Correct structural deficiencies. Add warning sign (temporary measure). | |
Weather conditions | Improve maintenance. Install warning signs (e.g. fog) |
|
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: SECTION-HEAD ON
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
Capacity | Single-vehicle crashes | Is the capacity adequate?
Passing opportunities Check whether passing opportunities are sufficient based on road category and traffic conditions (opposing direction gaps, passing lane).
|
Marking | Sideswipe collisions | Is the centre line clearly marked? Does marking clearly prohibit passing if hazardous? Is the marking clearly visible under all conditions (night, rain, sunset or sunrise, winter). |
Cross- section | Head-on collisions Sideswipe collisions
| Is the general aspect of the cross-section adequate for the road category and the traffic conditions (e.g. too-narrow lanes for heavy vehicles)? Are channelization features safe (curb height, alignment, end treatment)? Are rumble strips provided if required? Is transition adequate at cross-section changes (divided/undivided, lane drop)?
Climbing lane
|
Surface condition | Sideswipe collisions | Check for hazardous manoeuvres that may be related to surface deficiencies (potholes, waves, water accumulation, etc.). |
Drivers’ behaviour |
| Check for hazardous passing manoeuvres. |
Weather conditions | Crashes under adverse weather conditions (rain, fog, etc.) | Plan the site visit when adverse conditions are likely to be observed. |
POSSIBLES ACTIONS: SECTION-HEAD ON
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
Capacity | Add a traffic lane (or passing lane). Prohibit passing manoeuvres (marking, median barrier). Improve road signs (distance to the next passing lane). Promote alternative routes or transportation solution (e.g. transit). | |
Marking | Improve marking. |
|
Cross- section | Widen lanes or shoulders. Improve shoulder condition. Add channelization. Provide rumble strips. |
|
Surface condition | Proceed to superficial surface treatment (grooving, sandblasting, etc.) Resurface. Improve drainage conditions. Correct surface deficiencies. Add warning sign (temporary measure). | |
Drivers’ behaviour | Improve road signs. Increase drivers’ education. Increase police enforcement. Install surveillance cameras. | |
Weather conditions | Improve maintenance. Install warning signs (e.g. fog) |
|
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: SECTION - PEDESTRIAN/CYCLIST
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
Insufficient protection |
| Are existing facilities providing adequate protection for pedestrians and cyclists?
Have safety needs of all pedestrian categories been properly considered (baby carriages, children, elderly people, disabled persons, wheelchairs)?
|
Coherence |
| Is the continuity of pedestrian/cyclist facilities provided along their routes? Are pedestrian/cyclist crossings located at the right place (based on their itineraries)? (see also Intersection - Pedestrian/cyclist) |
Illegal use of pedestrian facilities |
| Have adequate measures been taken to avoid illegal use of pedestrian or cyclist facilities (parked vehicles, stands, other obstacles)? |
Behaviour |
| Are pedestrians using their facilities? |
Visibility |
| Are pedestrians/cyclists clearly visible? |
Road lighting | Nighttime crashes | Check the frequency of night crashes. Check the presence and condition of the road lighting system (at night). Are pedestrian and cyclist facilities adequate for night usage (if required)? |
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: SECTION - PEDESTRIAN/CYCLIST
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS |
Insufficient protection | Provide footways, bicycle paths. Increase lateral offset of pedestrian/cyclist facilities. Install physical barriers between motorized and non-motorized traffic. Implement traffic-calming measures. At crossings: see Intersections - pedestrians/cyclists. |
Coherence | Ensure continuity of pedestrian/cyclist facilities along their itineraries. Relocate crossings based on pedestrian (cyclist routes) |
Illegal use of pedestrian facilities | Add parking prohibition signs. Provide barriers between pedestrians/cyclists and motorized vehicles. Modify traffic regulations. Increase police enforcement. |
Behaviour | Increase driver/pedestrian/cyclist education. Increase police enforcement. |
Visibility | Remove sight obstructions (e.g. parking along the road). Install warning signs/devices. |
Road lighting | Install or improve road lighting |
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: GENERAL - NIGHT
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
Road lighting |
| Check for the presence and condition of the road lighting system. |
Road sign Marking |
| Are signs and marking retro-reflectivity adequate at night? |
Behaviour |
| Check for excessive speeds, compliance with traffic rules. |
The site visit should be conducted at night
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: GENERAL - NIGHT
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS |
Road lighting | Install or improve road lighting. |
Road sign Marking | Improve road signs/markings. |
Behaviour | Increase drivers’ education. Increase police enforcement. |
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS: GENERAL - WET SURFACE
FACTORS | OTHER CRASH TYPES | OBSERVATIONS/MEASURES/CALCULATIONS |
Surface condition | Rear-end collisions | Is skid resistance adequate?
|
Excessive speed | Rear-end collisions Single-vehicle crashes | Are operating speeds compatible with safe traffic operation (based on road characteristics and traffic conditions)? |
POSSIBLE ACTIONS: GENERAL - WET SURFACE
FACTORS | POSSIBLE ACTIONS | REFERENCES |
Surface condition | Proceed to superficial surface treatments (grooving, sand blasting, etc). Resurface. Improve drainage conditions. Correct structural deficiencies. Add warning sign (temporary measure). | |
Excessive speed | Improve visibility of speed limit signs. Implement traffic-calming measures. Increase drivers’ education and police enforcement. Install red-light camera. |